I put Middle Earth Journal in hiatus in May of 2008 and moved to Newshoggers.
I temporarily reopened Middle Earth Journal when Newshoggers shut it's doors but I was invited to Participate at The Moderate Voice so Middle Earth Journal is once again in hiatus.

Friday, August 24, 2007

Say it slowly: This. Is. A. Lie

Kevin Drum is on a roll today debunking "the surge is a success" meme. As I reported below Kevin compared June/July, 06 with June/July, 07 and according to most of the metrics 07 was worse than 06. Now he takes a part a talking point that is simply an outright lie.
...but it's this passage that makes me want to bang my head against the wall:
The fact is that the surge is President Bush's policy, and one that he implemented over the vociferous opposition of Democrats who thought the best strategy against al Qaeda in Iraq was to begin to leave. Now the surge has helped turn Sunni tribes against al Qaeda, advancing the goal that nearly everyone in the U.S. notionally shares of routing the terror group from Iraq.
Say it slowly: This. Is. A. Lie. The Sunni tribes began turning against AQI nearly a year ago. They did it on their own, not as part of any American military plan. They did it before the surge started. They did it before Gen. Petraeus was even a gleam in George Bush's eye. Here's the truth:
The turnabout began last September, when a federation of tribes in the Ramadi area came together as the Anbar Salvation Council to oppose the fundamentalist militants of Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia.

....The council sought financial and military support from the Iraqi and American governments. In return the sheiks volunteered hundreds of tribesmen for duty as police officers and agreed to allow the construction of joint American-Iraqi police and military outposts throughout their tribal territories.

....Beginning last summer and continuing through March, the American-led joint forces pressed into the city, block by block, and swept the farmlands on its outskirts. In many places the troops met fierce resistance. Scores of American and Iraqi security troops were killed or wounded.
The Anbar Awakening is genuinely good news, but (a) it had nothing to do with the surge, (b) it's happening only in homogeneous Sunni areas, and (c) it involves arming and training Sunni forces who are almost certain to turn against both us and the Shiite central government as soon as they've finished off AQI. Pretending otherwise is simply fraudulent.
Also below I noted that both Josh Marshall and Atrios think that Bush/Cheney and the neocons are just trying to keep the occupation going as long as they can in hopes that some miracle will occur and their debacle will turn out all right after all. I think that many of the neocons know that it's a lost cause but want to stretch it out until 2009 so they can try to blame the "liberals" for their folly. In order to do that they just make shit up and lie. It appears that not only are the Republicans buying it but way too many Democrats are too.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Be Nice