I put Middle Earth Journal in hiatus in May of 2008 and moved to Newshoggers.
I temporarily reopened Middle Earth Journal when Newshoggers shut it's doors but I was invited to Participate at The Moderate Voice so Middle Earth Journal is once again in hiatus.

Saturday, January 08, 2005

Hey, it worked for the Romans

Georg found this fantastic op-ed in the LA TImes by Johathan Chait. He proposes that, rather than just going back to puritanical era values in this country, we say "screw it" and go all the way back to pre-Christian era values. His idea? Rather than invading other countries, we just start demanding that they pay tribute into the U.S. treasury.

<>
<>In the old days, before the rise of fuzzy-minded liberal internationalists, it was considered utterly normal for powerful states to force their weaker neighbors to hand over money or material goods as a price for avoiding military punishment. Although unfair, it was a reasonably effective method for preventing wars.

Rather than go through the full invade-kill-burn-plunder cycle, which took a lot out of invader and invadee alike, both sides found it easier and more humane to simply skip straight ahead to the last stage. It worked for the Romans, the Byzantines, the Ottomans and the various peoples fortunate enough to share borders with them.

Implementing the policy would be quite simple. We would inform heads of militarily vulnerable states that if they did not wish to have their regime changed — or, at least, to have large chunks of it blown to smithereens — they had better make an annual contribution to the U.S. Treasury. I envision receiving sums more than sufficient to cover our budget deficit.

Sure, this may strain diplomatic relations. But most of the world hates us anyway. How much worse can it get? If we're going to be an international pariah, we might as well enjoy some benefit from it.


This solves a bunch of problems in one go, people. First, we don't get our soldiers killed in foolish, needless wars. Second, we pay off the deficit that Bush is running up with his tax cuts for the rich without having to recind those same tax cuts. And last, we can sneer at and humiliate a hell of a lot more countries simultaneously under this plan than we can by invading them.


Don't tell anyone, but I think this Chait guy is on to something here.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Be Nice